Re: ranma ML 1 hour matome okuri


to ranma@ML.usagi.org
cc Kasumi-Kawaii@asianavenue.com
from "Kasumi Kawaii" <kasumi-kawaii@asianavenue.com>
subject Re: ranma ML 1 hour matome okuri
date Wed, 8 Aug 2001 16:17:47 -0700
*Hai! Hai! Does the name Hitomi Ichinohei mean anything to you?
      
>I'd wager less than 10 people here remember Hitomi from the ML proper,
>though more might be familiar with the name from the "Clothes Make the Man"
>fanfic collaboration with NightElf.
      
>Regardless, and although it's been many years since he was on the ML, I
>don't remember him being treated that badly here. I heard there was some
>kind of fallout on the *FF*ML, and possibly a newsgroup or two. I suppose
>I can check the archives for early-mid 1997 to see for certain.

-Bradster

I suppose it is a matter of perspective.  I was told that Hitomi-San was 
RIDICULED off the ML because of intollerance, as I was ALSO told that 
Hitomi-San was a transsexual.  I have never been able to contact Hitomi-San, 
but I cannot blame her for not writing back.  I am sure she thinks that I am 
simply another person who would try to crush her soul.  That is what *I* 
might think in her place.
 
      
I began collecting all her fan-fics, including "Clothes Make The..." which is 
(to me) perhaps the greatest Ranma fan-fic ever written.  Most certainly the 
best I have read so far.  Not because of the subject, but because all the 
loose ends in the Ranma story line were tied up very neatly.  I would like to 
think that the original Takahashi story-line WOULD have ended that way.  It 
was extrremely logical and fit very well into the format of the story line.
 
      
But if Hitomi-San IS a transsexual, it is not very nice to use masculine 
pronouns in refference to her.  I try to give everyone the benefit of the 
doubt.  How we define ourselves can sometimes be quite different from how 
other people see us.  I understand these things differently than other people 
do because I myself am closer to that situation than I might want to admit.
 
      
I had not realized that there was also a "fan-fic" ML as well...  The person 
who told me all about Hitomi-San (who will not be named here) is someone who 
is quite respected in Ranma Fandom.  If I said the name, you would know them 
immediately.
 
      
What breaks my heart is that there is so much prejudice against people like 
Hitomi-San.  The government of Japan is itself intollerant of transsexuals, 
and the surgery to change sex is still illegal in Japan.  This is why I had 
always hoped thet the "Jusenkyou legend" were real.  Besides, Nabiki-Chan 
says that it would sure save a bundle on the cost of surgery.  ^_^
 
      
But... even IF one somehow manages to survive long enough to be in the 
position to obtain corrective surgery, the government still does not accord 
them full rights based on their new sex, so on passports and drivers' 
licenses and such things, a male-to-female transsexual (who is now physically 
female) is STILL registered under her original sex.  In Japan, one can never 
escape the shame of being considered less than a man.
 
      
But YHIS country is even worse!  In 1982, the United States Supreme Court 
held up a lower court decision that said that ALL transsexuals, whether they 
are male-to-female, female-to-male, pre-op or post-op, are not legally human. 
 (r.e. Karen Ulane vs. Eastern Airlines.)  Under their definition, someone 
like Hitomi-San HAS no sex and is therefore NOT human.  This is why Federal 
law refuses to give transsexuals equal rights and equal protection under the 
law.  
 
       
But...  If you follow history, you will KNOW that declaring a group of people 
to be "non-human" is just the FIRST STEP to exterminating them.  This is why 
I do not wish to be an American citizen.  There is NO liberty and justice for 
all as long as ANY group of people are deprioved of their rights as human 
beings, which are given to them by God, NOT the government.  I do not support 
ANY government that takes away a person's humanity.
 
      


Sent by AsianAvenue.com Internet Mail

http://www.AsianAvenue.com  "Click into Asian America"

Search field Search string

archive list

unauthorized access prohibited
MLtools V3.1 Copyright (c) Usagi Labs