To: ranma@ML.usagi.org Date: Wed, 01 Sep 1999 11:04:33 -0700 From: "Under World" Message-ID: Subject: fanfic discussion Reply-To: ranma@ML.usagi.org X-ML-archive: http://www.win.ne.jp/~doi/ML/ Precedence: bulk >General Questions: > >Could the story fit in the regular Ranmaverse? definitely, maybe it's one of the few fanfics that I've read that holds on to the true spirit of Ranma, instead of getting dark >Was anyone noticeably OOC? >(specifically address Ranma, Akane, and Nodoka) at the beggining the premise of Nodoka thinking of Girl days was, for me, unbelievable, but as the fic moved on it seemed more possible Ranma may be more thoughtful, but that would be a consequence of seeing everything from other point of view >Were there any noticeable author biases? none that I could think of >Any favourite quotes? none that I can remember, but ------- | >Did you enjoy the fanfic? | | sure, made me laugh often <---------- >=================== >Story-specific questions: > >Would Ranma ever, in a month of Mondays, actually agree to the Girl Days? if the only person that he would obey asked him, and that's Nodoka >Would Ranma ever, in a month of Mondays, actually go out with Ryouga? as long as it is a challenge, yes >Did the author do a good job of dealing with some of the more "feminine >aspects" of Ranma's curse? I suppose I'll be mercilessly derided if I don't >just say it - In other words, did he deal well with the sort of stuff that >Takahashi terms "I don't think about it, and neither should you."? (PMS, the >possibility of pregnancy, and the like) yes, maybe those were the most funny parts of the fic >Was the author's continual commentary/fourth-wall breaking distraction, or >did it work in this case? yes, and even if it was without the context I thought it was funny >What did you think of the final (as of now) costume-party chaos scene at the >Kunou estate? that's the part I liked the less of the fic, like it went down on history, because even if it could happen in Nerima that mess was more out of the true Ranmaverse than the rest of the story >Has this story changed your impression of cheez whiz? ^_^ what? it was food all the time? --== Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ ==-- Share what you know. Learn what you don't.